Beyond the Referral

Managing Cross-Selling Risk for Broker-Dealers

As mid-tier broker-dealers (BDs) compete with Canada’s Big 5 banks, many are leveraging their client-facing advisors to refer clients to third-party providers such as mortgages, credit cards, and deposit accounts, with the goal of deepening relationships and reducing client attrition. While the strategy is sound, the regulatory risks are real. What begins as a simple referral can quickly escalate into a compliance issue if not carefully managed. Since advisors are licensed for securities, not lending or banking, firms must tread carefully to avoid misrepresentation, undisclosed conflicts, or unregistered activity.

The Referral Model Meets Regulatory Reality

Financial advisors are often the gateway to a client’s broader financial life. But referring clients to external institutions, especially for compensation, engages multiple regulatory bodies, including:

• CIRO (advisor conduct, conflicts, holding out)

• Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) (referral arrangements, registration requirements)

• FCAC (fair treatment of consumers, coercive selling)

• Provincial regulators (mortgage and insurance distribution)

Advisors must not present themselves as mortgage or credit specialists unless separately licensed. Compensation must be disclosed, clients must retain full choice, and firms must ensure that referrals are made in the client’s best interest, not the advisor’s.

Practical Risks

• Undisclosed compensation or bias in referrals

• Improper holding out (advisors acting outside their registration)

• Perceived coercion (for example, suggesting banking products are required for wealth services)

• Referrals to unregistered or unvetted third parties

Even unintentional missteps in these areas can result in reputational damage or regulatory scrutiny.

Referrals open new paths, but without controls the journey can veer off course.

Best Practices for Broker-Dealers

To ensure compliance while preserving strategic flexibility:

1. Establish Clear Referral Policies

   Define who can be referred, under what terms, and with what disclosures. Ensure all agreements are documented.

   
   

2. Train Advisors on Boundaries

   Educate on what they can and cannot say, especially around non-securities products or dual licensing.

   
   

3. Embed Disclosure into Client Journeys

   Whether in person or digital, ensure referral rationale, compensation, and alternatives are transparently shared.

   
   

4. Strengthen Compliance Oversight

   Compliance teams should:

   • Log and track referral activity, including volume and compensation.

   • Test advisor communications, including call scripts, emails, and digital interactions.

   • Conduct mystery shopping or sample client calls to detect inappropriate language or coercion.

   • Review patterns of referral partners used disproportionately by specific advisors.

   
   

5. Monitor Conflicts Proactively

   Use conflict registers and conduct periodic reviews to identify emerging risks or trends across the advisor network.

   
   

The Bottom Line

Referral strategies can protect and grow client relationships, but only when executed within a robust compliance framework. BDs that embed regulatory discipline into their cross-product efforts will not just avoid penalties, they will earn client trust and future-proof their business against competitive threats.

For more practical insights on financial services, follow CMBYND on LinkedIn and subscribe to our newsletter CMBYND Thinking.